The Advantages and Disadvantages of Internal vs. External Hiring: Finding the Right Talent Acquisition Approach

When organisations have a job opening, they often face the decision of whether to hire  internally or externally. Internal hiring refers to filling a position with an existing employee,  while external hiring involves bringing in new talent from outside the organisation.

Both approaches have their advantages and disadvantages; understanding them is crucial in making informed talent acquisition decisions.

In this blog, we will explore the benefits and drawbacks of internal and external hiring to  help you find the right approach for your organisation.

 

Advantages of Internal Hiring

Familiarity with the Organisation

One significant advantage of internal hiring is that internal candidates are already familiar with the organisation’s culture, processes and values. They have a better understanding of the company’s goals, vision and operations, allowing for a smoother transition into the new role.

Internal hires require less time to get up to speed, as they have already demonstrated their competency and alignment with the organisation.

Boosting Employee Morale and Engagement

Promoting from within can boost employee morale and motivation. When employees see their colleagues being recognised and rewarded for their skills and hard work, it creates a sense of upward mobility and growth opportunities within the organisation.

This can increase overall job satisfaction, engagement and loyalty among existing  employees, leading to higher retention rates.

 

Cost and Time Savings

Internal hiring can save organisations time and money. Since internal candidates are already part of the organisation, the hiring process can be expedited. There is no need for extensive external recruitment efforts, advertising or conducting lengthy interviews.

Moreover, internal hires often require less training and onboarding compared to external candidates, resulting in cost savings for the organisation.

 

Disadvantages of Internal Hiring

Limited Fresh Perspectives

One drawback of internal hiring is the potential lack of fresh perspectives and new ideas. Internal candidates may have been immersed in the organisation’s current practices and may be less likely to challenge the status quo or bring in external best practices.

This can hinder innovation and limit the organisation’s ability to adapt to changing market dynamics.

 

Narrow Talent Pool

Internal hiring limits the pool of candidates to existing employees, which may not always provide the best fit for the role or bring in the desired skill set. Certain positions may require specialised knowledge or expertise that is not readily available within the organisation.

Relying solely on internal hires can limit diversity in perspectives and experiences,  potentially impacting creativity and problem-solving capabilities.

 

Advantages of External Hiring

Access to Fresh Skills and Expertise

External hiring allows organisations to tap into a broader talent pool, increasing the  chances of finding candidates with specialised skills, industry knowledge, or experience in specific areas. By bringing in external talent, organisations can infuse new ideas, perspectives, and approaches, driving innovation and growth.

 

Fostering Diversity and Inclusion

External hiring can contribute to a more diverse and inclusive workforce. By actively seeking candidates from different backgrounds, experiences, and perspectives,  organisations can build a more representative team.

This diversity can lead to enhanced creativity, improved decision-making and a broader range of skills and knowledge within the organisation.

 

Disadvantages of External Hiring

Longer Onboarding and Adjustment Period

External hires typically require a longer onboarding and adjustment period compared to internal hires. They need time to understand the organisation’s culture, processes and  internal dynamics

It may take longer for them to become fully productive and integrated into the team, which can temporarily impact overall efficiency.

 

Potential Disruption and Employee Morale

Bringing in external talent can sometimes disrupt the existing team dynamics, particularly if  there are internal candidates who were overlooked for the role.

This may lead to decreased morale and a perception that opportunities for growth are  limited within the organisation.

 

In conclusion, when considering whether to pursue internal or external hiring,  organisations must carefully weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each approach. Internal hiring promotes organisational continuity, leverages existing talent and boosts  employee morale.

On the other hand, external hiring offers access to fresh skills, perspectives, and a broader talent pool. Striking the right balance between internal and external hires can lead to a dynamic and successful workforce.

Ultimately, the decision should align with the organisation’s goals, specific job  requirements and long-term talent strategy.

 

Get in touch with us today to find out how best to acquire your talent.

Staffing Platform

Total workforce management. Zero aggravation.

Data-driven hiring & workforce management.
A revolution in recruitment. Unique to Workforce.

Find out more

Costs Calculator

For Permanent Recruitment

See how much you can save compared to a traditional recruitment agency.

Find out more

Case studies

Recent examples of how we help you cut Cost-Per-Hire and Time-To-Hire…

Employer reviews

See what other employers say about working with Workforce…

Working with you

You can expect the highest level of results AND customer service…

Online inductions

Avoid staff downtime by letting us help new starts hit the ground running…

eLearning

Our online training courses that boost your workforce productivity…

Meet The Team

It’s our superb team that continue to drive the success of Workforce…

Work @ Workforce

We invest in our people and provide excellent rewards and perks. Experience in recruitment is not necessarily a must-have. The right attitude is what matters most. Find out more…

News & Insights

Catch up with our news and industry insights here…

Hidden Labour Exploitation

We work closely with all our customers, the police and other organisations to ensure we identify and protect people who may be being exploited and/or trafficked.  Find out more…

About Us

Staffing & Recruitment solutions across the UK.

Every year we recruit and provide thousands of first-rate, productive workers to over 700 businesses – from SMEs to PLCs – covering a wide variety of positions from manual handling to C-Suite level.

Find out more

Industrial & Warehouse

For all your Warehouse & Factory roles including: Warehouse Operatives, Pickers & Packers, Assembly Operatives, General Labour, FLT drivers etc…

Driving & Logistics

For all your Driving roles including: Class 1, Class 2, 7.5 tonne, van drivers, delivery drivers etc…

Manufacturing & Engineering

For all your Manufacturing roles including: Welders, Press Brake Operators, Paint Sprayers, Mechanical Assemblers, CNC Operators etc…

Food

Manufacturing

For Food Manufacturing roles including: Production Operatives, Food Packers, Filling Operatives, Machine Operators, Quality Supervisors etc…

Professional

Services

For Professional roles inc: Accounts & Finance, Call Centre, Customer Service, Legal, HR, Manufacturing, Engineers, Quality, Sales, Supply Chain etc…

More

More

More

More

More

Flexible Temporary Staffing

Fill and flex your workforce almost instantly with daily demand…

Onsite Managed Workforce

Combine Flexible Temp Staffing with a dedicated WF account team onsite…

Flat Fee Staffing

Recruit perm staff at a flat-fee per-hire, with staged payments for reduced risk…

iHire - Hiring power

Hiring power to make your recruiting easier, quicker and cost (much!) less…

Permanent Recruitment

Search, Retained and Contingent recruitment for first-class hires at all levels…

Brilliant Recruitment

Can-do workforce solutions. For whatever happens.

Our mission is to deliver real, demonstrable cost savings to employers while ensuring you always have the quantity and quality of staff you need at any one time – from a single individual to hundreds of people. 

Find out more

Case studies

Recent examples of how we help you cut Cost-Per-Hire and Time-To-Hire…

Employer reviews

See what other employers say about working with Workforce…

Working with you

You can expect the highest level of results AND customer service…

Online inductions

Avoid staff downtime by letting us help new starts hit the ground running…

eLearning Courses

Our online training courses that boost your workforce productivity…

Staffing Platform

Total workforce management. Zero aggravation.

Fill and flex your shifts in seconds using our unique “Staffing Platform” recruitment tech and “Shftr” our integrated mobile app for workers.  Managing every aspect of your workforce has never been so easy.

Find out more

Get in touch

Back to News & Insights

More News & Insights